Thomas Made up Characters and Episodes Wiki

Another Great Arguement is the thirty-eighth episode of the fourth season.

"I'm gonna pull te train, not you"

"Och, muckle non-sense I do it"

"No, it'll be me"

"Will not"

"Will too"

-Donald and Douglas fighting over who will pull the New Year's Train at Mid-Night

Another Great Arguement
Season 4, Episode 38
Air date December 31, 2011 (New Year's Eve)
Written by HenryDashPaxton3000
Directed by HenryDashPaxton3000
Episode guide
Douglas' Revenge
Douglas' Special Train


Donald and Douglas are STILL cross and mad at eachother so The Fat Controller decides to have Douglas pull the Special Train later that day so and leave Donald open to talk some sense into him. So, later The Fat Controller comes aboard The Truck and Percy and tells Douglas he'll get to pull the Special Train if he apoligizes. Douglas does so and The Fat Controller has only Donald to go. However Gordon tells Donald that his twin will pull the Special Train, very annoyed he quickly goes to bump him off the Rails, but Percy coming out of the Siding is bumped instead. He falls down into a lake. His Driver hurt his leg. His Fireman just has some scrapes. The Fat Controller send Donald to The Siding. As he passes Douglas, he whispers that it'll serve him right. The Fat Controller decides to forgive only Douglas then he sends Gordon to The Siding too.


  • Douglas
  • The Fat Controller
  • Donald
  • Gordon
  • Percy (non-speaking role)
  • The Truck (non-speaking role)


  • Tidmouth Sheds (Stock Footage)
  • A Siding
  • The Sidind (mentioned)


  • This is Part 1 of The New Year's Special.
  • Stock Footage from Douglas' Revenge is used.